Read Portions Of Killer Mike, Big Boi & T.I’s Supreme Court Brief Filed In Defense Of Hip Hop

(AllHipHop News) Atlanta-based rap stars Big Boi, Killer Mike, and T.I. are defending a Mississippi high school student’s First Amendment rights. The trio is among a host of concerned citizens that filed a brief to the United States Supreme Court on why rap music is an art form protected by the Constitution.

[ALSO READ: Killer Mike Talks Politics, Social Justice, Donald Trump & More With Bernie Sanders (VIDEO)]

Taylor Bell (aka T-Bizzle) was suspended from his high school in 2011 after releasing a song about two school coaches accused of sexually harassing other students. The allegations have not been denied by the school. Bell was forced to transfer, and he later sued his original school. While he lost in a lower court, he is now hoping the Supreme Court will take his case.

Killer Mike, T.I., and Big Boi were also joined by Pharoahe Monch and Jasiri X in adding their names to the brief filed on behalf of Bell. Erik Nielson of the University of Richmond, Charis E. Kubrin of the University of California-Irvine, and Travis L. Gosa of Cornell University are among the main authors. Professors from several universities including USC, Columbia, Georgetown, Northwestern, and UCLA also signed on as friends of the court supporting Bell.

The brief references the artistic value of several Hip Hop acts including Afrika Bambaataa, Jay Z, Tupac Shakur, Eminem, Nas, Snoop Dogg, Ice Cube, Kendrick Lamar, Joey Bada$$, and more.

[ALSO READ: N.J. Supreme Court Rules Rap Lyrics Cannot Be Used As Evidence In Case]

Check out some of the passages from the amici curiae brief for “Taylor Bell v. Itawamba County School Board” below.

Hip Hop history/Afrika Bambaataa

Hip hop—a cultural movement comprised of performance arts such as MCing (“rapping”), DJing (“spinning”), breakdancing (“b-boying”), and graffiti (“writing”)—began as a response to these dire conditions. Pioneers like Afrika Bambaataa (once a gang leader himself) used spiritual and political consciousness (“knowledge of self”) to develop hip hop as a tool for ending gang violence by providing an outlet that transformed the inherent competitiveness and territoriality of gang life into something artistic and productive. Dance competitions, rap battles, and other competitive performances replaced actual fighting, and rap in particular eventually became an alternative, legal source of income for blacks and Latinos otherwise cut off from labor market opportunities.

Jay Z

In his memoir, Decoded, Jay-Z—one of the best-selling artists in history—recounts being following around New York City by the same “hip hop cop” for seven years and, at one point, being arrested for no reason other than so police could “paint the picture of me as a menace to society.” JAYZ, DECODED 162 (2011). Jay-Z explains why rappers, as opposed to artists in other genres, receive such treatment: “The difference is obvious, of course: 11 Rappers are young black men telling stories that the police, among others, don’t want to hear.”


Perhaps recognizing the transformative power of hip hop, both in the U.S. and abroad, the Vatican included the song Changes by Tupac Shakur (a rapper well known for using violent rhetoric to attack institutions of power) on its official MySpace playlist in 2009. Jo Piazza, Tupac Song Selected for Vatican Playlist, CNN (Dec. 4, 2009). The song includes lyrics like “Give the crack to the kids, who the hell cares, one less hungry mouth on the welfare” and “My stomach hurts, so I’m looking for a purse to snatch.” The Vatican— unlike the Disciplinary Committee and Fifth Circuit—apparently recognized the difference between artistic expression and literal truth.

Like Tupac Shakur, Taylor Bell was using his music to effect changes. In the final portion of the video for his song PSK da Truth, Bell says that in rapping about sexual misconduct at his high school, he is trying to raise awareness about similar injustices around the world: “It’s something that’s been going on, you know, worldwide for a long time that I just felt like, you know, I needed to address.”


Songs like Ether reveal some of the most basic characteristics of rap as a creative form. Not only is the genre imbued with an inherent sense of competitiveness, it also is “a complex linguistic art where words are constantly in flux, changing meanings and intentions, texture and sound.” ADAM BRADLEY, BOOK OF RHYMES: THE POETICS OF HIP HOP 89 (2009).


The decision by the court of appeals punishes a student for his art—and perpetuates unfair and inaccurate stereotypes—by mischaracterizing often used rap music phrases as “threats.” The decision either failed to understand, or failed to acknowledge, Taylor Bell’s rap song as artistic expression. As a result, Bell’s petition for certiorari should be granted.

  • DollasTX

    Nuff respect!

  • NCcatsBALLhard

    Cats hate on rappers from the South but look at what they’re doing. Much respect to all artists involved especially Killer Mike…

    • that dude

      Not all, just some. Killer Mike been dope tho.

    • illatouch

      Ugh im pretty sure the hate goes toward the future/rich homie/yung thug types. Not southern rappers who actually have lyrics.

      • NCcatsBALLhard

        Naw this is the internet. They lump the whole South in the same category.

      • 1KillMovez1

        Smh stop paying attention to the internet then… Everybody obviously knos the difference between good/bad southern rappers.

  • Pingback: Read Portions Of Killer Mike, Big Boi & T.I’s Supreme Court Brief Filed In Defense Of Hip Hop()

  • Hakeem

    What exactly is this lawsuit about?
    We all know hip-hop and rap is free speech…
    FYI… 99.9 percent of southern rap is trash……

    • RapItUp

      On the strength of Big Boi and Killer Mike alone, your statement is null and voided out. TI once upon a time used to be decent. Not hard to continue naming other viable southern acts that aren’t trash. FTR, NY gritty rap is my favorite style of rap hands down, but I can name one trash NY rapper for every young thug and/or soulja boy you spew out. As I could from any coast. Listen to the music.. Don’t skim through it.

      • Hakeem

        I listen they are just mumbling from what I hear….

      • RapItUp

        all 99.99% though? come on homie.. don’t troll.. at least say 92%.. 99 is reaching, still. I understand your dilemma.. I like to understand what I’m listening to.. but your bias is showing.

    • golder1

      The lawsuit is about this school suspending this kid over lyrics about a teacher sexually harrasing students, something the school doesnt deny happended. Basically this is a 1st amendments case

  • Hakeem

    I know he dont think he is breaking some new ground here?
    2 live crew paved the way on that front…..

  • Q.

    Let this be a lesson: As long as you rap about debauchery and bullsh!t, you can get all the airtime your little heart desires. As soon as you put some real shit in a rhyme…SHUT DOWN TIME. The game is rigged. #LYRICSMATTER

  • Pingback: Read Portions Of Killer Mike, Big Boi & T.I’s Supreme Court Brief Filed In Defense Of Hip Hop | HUEY mix wit RILEY()

  • MrNoName2K

    Thats whats up. Big salute to these brothers right here..

  • Pingback: Hip-Hop News, Rumors, Rap Music & Videos |AllHipHop » Killer Mike Wrote The Foreword For Marvel’s Hip Hop Covers Comic Book()

  • Pingback: Hip-Hop News, Rumors, Rap Music & Videos |AllHipHop »Vegas, Baby: Big Boi Locks Down Wynn Las Vegas Residency()