Game Review: Ikaruga (Xbox Live)
1 hour, 38 minutes ago | 1

Sound-Off: Really R. Kelly?
10 hours, 8 minutes ago | 19








Game Review: Grand Theft Auto IV
Published Wednesday, May 07, 2008 2:00 PM
by Alex Thornton

 

Publisher: Rockstar Games

Platform: PS3, Xbox 360 (tested on both for this review)

Rating: 10 out of 10

 

 

Somewhere in the world right now, a woman is threatening to break up with her boyfriend and he doesn’t particularly care. Phone calls are going unanswered, homework is going undone and sick days are being used all for the same reason.

 

Grand Theft Auto IV has arrived, and Playstation 3 and Xbox 360 owners the world over are hypnotized by a fantasy life of crime.

 

While GTAIV is actually the fifth sequel since 2001’s III, it’s the first to appear on this generation of consoles and incorporate online play (as if GTA wasn’t addicting enough).

 

Series vets should still feel right at home since the core elements of the game haven’t changed, but there’s new depth added to every element of the game that makes it feel fresh no matter how many hours you logged on previous versions.

 

The story retains the same biting humor that’s become a series trademark, but this time the protagonist (Eastern European immigrant Niko Bellic) actually has a sense of morality and a complex motivation. You’ll commit your fair share of random acts of violence, but at several points in the story, you’ll have the option of executing or sparing certain characters and your choices affect how Niko’s peers view him.

 

The grand scheme of the story doesn’t change much depending on your choices, but there are missions that you will or won’t get based on who you kill. At one point, two of your associates will call asking you to take out the other, creating a surprisingly strong moral conflict. Killing one will mean missing out on a big financial benefit, but killing the other just feels wrong.

 

Will you bite the hand that feeds you to spare the innocent man or push your guilt aside and do the job you’re being paid for? Deciding is harder than you might expect, and the fact that you even have a choice gives the story mode an element of replay value that the past games never had.

 

To cut down on the tedious legwork for those multiple playthroughs, Rockstar has added a few elements that gamers have been begging for. For starters, you can always catch a cab and have it take you more or less anywhere for a few bucks. That alone is a huge time saver, especially since the more aggressive cops make you think twice about jacking cars that you don’t really need.

 

In addition, you now have a cell phone that you can use to communicate with your friends, employers and girlfriends. The bad news is that just like in real life, the phone is a huge pain in the ass. You’ll get phone calls fairly frequently (even during other missions) from people who need favors or just want to hang out. It’s always up to you to accept their requests or even answer at all, but every time you ignore a friend, their feelings get hurt and they’ll be less likely to do favors for you down the road.

 

The game quickly becomes about juggling the needs of your contacts, so get used to your girlfriends calling while you’re across town jacking a motorcycle to sell to a dealer. It feels silly to ignore your real life phone to play a game about a phone that never stops ringing, but your actual friends probably aren’t calling to put a hit out on a crooked coke dealer either.

 

The individual calls are aggravating at times, but it’s actually a great system that keeps the pace up. Even when you’re just ambling around, you’ll always have something better to do than aimlessly murder citizens, though if that’s what you’re into, you can always turn the phone off and temporarily suspend the story mode.

 

You can also use the phone at any time to jump right into the new online modes. Like the single-player game, you have free-reign to do whatever you like online so it’s easy to make your own fun and invent things to do with your friends. Just roaming around launching rockets at each other is fun as it is, but there are a ton of creative mission-based modes to participate in when you need a change.

 

In one particularly creative mode, players choose to either be cops or gangsters in a wild variation of Capture the Flag. One crook is assigned the V.I.P. role and the others have to help him get to a specific point across town while the cop players are tasked with hunting him down.


You can’t win by just running around hurling bullets and it takes a satisfying amount of strategy and teamwork to pull it off. Throw in the variety of races, vehicle fights and custom games and GTAIV online adds up to way more than anyone would’ve expected for their first attempt.

 

For those that have both systems, choosing which version to buy isn’t simple. On the 360’s side, there will eventually be a few additional missions to purchase that supposedly won’t be available for the PS3. On the other hand, the visuals are more impressive on Sony’s console and the load times are noticeably shorter.


You can’t go wrong either way, but the PS3’s smoother frame rate and quick loading are a bigger long-term benefit than the extra missions, so that version has the edge.

 

With the exception of some odd adjustments to the driving controls, everything about GTAIV is at least as good as, if not better than, the last major installment. San Andreas was already pretty close to perfect, so while the changes aren’t huge, there was no need to reinvent the wheel.

 

There’s a reason why everyone you know is talking about this game; Grand Theft Auto IV is probably the most hyped title in recent memory, but it actually lives up to it.


Comments

 

htownzack said:

Every time this game comes out Rockstars able to follow through and make it better than the last and they definitely do on this one. Best game in years!!!
May 7, 2008 2:20 PM
 

JRucker said:

great game. i am having a blast
May 7, 2008 2:23 PM
 

bknewstash said:

This is the best game ever.You have to be from NY to truly appreciate how great this game is.
May 7, 2008 2:28 PM
 

JFrank2040 said:

Alot of Sony Fanboys in here.........

So if Sony does'nt get the extra content how is that the better version?
Also Sony does'nt have no where near the amount of people online that Xbox Live has, so how is that the better version?

The ONLY reason PS3 loads faster is because you MUST mandatorily INSTALL the game to your hardrive like PC games which takes any where from 10-20 mins.

Also PS3 users are experencing FREEZING in the game.


Ok now that I'm done, the game is great on either console on the visuals at times is Better on the Xbox 360 and at times on the PS3.

Ps3 has better particle effects, and the xbox has better lighting, either or visually is a tie.

The sole reason why the 36 version is better is becuase of the better online service, community, and extra game content that will ONLY be on Xbox as Microsoft paid $50 million for it.

Now have a nice day
,peace
May 7, 2008 2:28 PM
 

JRucker said:

JFrank2040 said:
Alot of Sony Fanboys in here.........

So if Sony does'nt get the extra content how is that the better version?
Also Sony does'nt have no where near the amount of people online that Xbox Live has, so how is that the better version?

The ONLY reason PS3 loads faster is because you MUST mandatorily INSTALL the game to your hardrive like PC games which takes any where from 10-20 mins.

Also PS3 users are experencing FREEZING in the game.


Ok now that I'm done, the game is great on either console on the visuals at times is Better on the Xbox 360 and at times on the PS3.

Ps3 has better particle effects, and the xbox has better lighting, either or visually is a tie.

The sole reason why the 36 version is better is becuase of the better online service, community, and extra game content that will ONLY be on Xbox as Microsoft paid $50 million for it.

Now have a nice day
,peace
_____________________________________________________

yeah... what he said!
May 7, 2008 2:36 PM
 

Bed-Stuy Ambassador Doug said:

 bknewstash said:
This is the best game ever.You have to be from NY to truly appreciate how great this game is.

It's a good game overall but if you arent from NY there are small things you wont pick up on(like the fact that the "beat" sounds exactly like hot 97 same dj's and promo guy). I just dont like the fact that it takes so long to start a multiplayer game. I just assume alot of people didnt get it yet
May 7, 2008 2:39 PM
 

G-RootTHEJudge said:

Dude you're fuckin biased.  I've played both systems quite extensively and have found it obvious PS3 has much better game play/graphics.  People will be glitching and going through walls and shit in XBox.  Don't be a hater just cuz you got a worse system for the game, and if you're gonna be, don't let out you're anger on a page where people are looking for honest comparisons.
May 7, 2008 2:46 PM
 

primaryimage said:

yeah i know two people with ps3's like 50 with 360.
--  elcapitangrande   --360 name holla at me.
May 7, 2008 2:52 PM
 

FLW_The_Producer said:

I dont own a PS3 but I love the 360 version hella nice I bought it yesterday I'm lovin it ...who cares what system you own this one on GTA 4 the shit on whatever system you own HOLLA
May 7, 2008 2:58 PM
 

JFrank2040 said:

I stated Facts, unlike  G-Root.

The gameplay is the same on BOTH consoles as it is the same game.
The graphics are equal, as PS3 has better explosions and AA, but the Xbox has better Lighting and sharpness.

The online community is NO comparison....

Xbox Live has wel over 10+ million users online, and the PS3 does'nt have a fraction of that.
So finding more games, more people, etc. is alot better on the Xbox side due to the amount of people.

Also the final blow like I stated is  Microsoft paid Rockstar and Take 2 $50 million dollars to deliver games EXCLUSIVE content that will ONLY be on Xbox.

So if ANYONE has any doubt which is the better version is crazy.

,peace
May 7, 2008 3:02 PM
 

Kiel B said:

Are two grown men arguing over a got-damn video game?
SMH
May 7, 2008 3:14 PM
 

D.I.C.E. said:

This shit is the biz, nuff said....
May 7, 2008 3:39 PM
 

wizwey21215 said:

its just a game its good on both systems lets not turn this into a beef over which one is better      







peace
May 7, 2008 3:54 PM
 

King High Pimpn said:

STS Runs GTA Multi player matches,,  PSN: Terrorist_Jones

Come Get some!!
May 7, 2008 4:08 PM
 

Hutch27 said:

S.T.S. We Run Liberty City!!!

a Terrorist_Jones i still need to learn how to use that damn Rocket Launcher lol, but we was still runnin that joint last night with just 3 people
May 7, 2008 4:29 PM
 

Don Won said:

STS in the building!

Already.  we were working everbody last night, people didn't even want to stay in the room.  
May 7, 2008 4:50 PM
 

brooklynbanger said:

gta IV is one of the most impressive games i played since god of war 2.i have both versions-the ps3 is great because of the controls and graphics.and besides there probably be like 5 bonus missions for the xbox360 which is not worth getting hyped over..the online is off the meter-deathmatch and team death match in which the whole city is open to your leisure..get at me PSN:dblock8282
May 7, 2008 4:54 PM
 

Don Won said:

 
JFrank2040 said:
I stated Facts, unlike  G-Root.

The gameplay is the same on BOTH consoles as it is the same game.
The graphics are equal, as PS3 has better explosions and AA, but the Xbox has better Lighting and sharpness.

The online community is NO comparison....

Xbox Live has wel over 10+ million users online, and the PS3 does'nt have a fraction of that.
So finding more games, more people, etc. is alot better on the Xbox side due to the amount of people.

Also the final blow like I stated is  Microsoft paid Rockstar and Take 2 $50 million dollars to deliver games EXCLUSIVE content that will ONLY be on Xbox.

So if ANYONE has any doubt which is the better version is crazy.

,peace


funny how you're calling out the sony fanboys but you seem like a MS fanboy yourself.  i have both systems and i chose the ps3 one, because the ps3 is a better system.  i've gone through 4 360's and i'm not the only one.  both systems have good qualities, xbox live on the 360 and just an overall better built system with the ps3.  i think i'd rather have the better built system.  last thing, xbox live is better, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with the PSN.  it don't have any problems with it, sony just needs to put the in-game xmb out and it'd be perfect.

do you even have a ps3 and played on the psn, or are you just talking out your ass?
May 7, 2008 4:55 PM
 

BIGGAR said:

Tight game, Mad detailed, and visually smooth.  
I've heard that it was rated better on the PS3 then the Xbox in about 10 reviews.  I haven't played the XBox joint but thats what I heard.  
I stopped playing games for a while except for the Madden series. But this game made me buy the PS3.  
Only flaw on the game is reading the text on the cellphone.  But maybe its my old ass t.v
May 7, 2008 5:03 PM
 

D.O.C said:

best game in years,probably of all time........................it's already made like $500 million already
May 7, 2008 5:05 PM
 

gurlgamer05 said:

i just want to say I love this game! GTA 4 is awesome!
May 7, 2008 5:07 PM
 

big4mat said:

YO BROOKYKLN BANGER WHATUP SON THIS IS BIG T IN TX WHAT IT IS? GTAIV IS CRAZY, I HAVE IT ON XBOX360, BUT I HAVE TO BUY IT FOR PS3 ALSO, I LOVE MY QUIET POWERFUL PS3 LOL...CHECK IT..GONNA GO COP IT IN A WEEK OR SO, AND I'LL GET UP WITH YOU BANGIN IN THE CITY FOR REAL..I HAVE UNCHARTED, NBA LIVE 08, MOTORSTORM WHICH CAME WITH MY 80 GB PS3 IF YOUHAVE ANY OF THOSE HOLLA, ALSO I GOT THAT ARMY OF TWO GOT THAT FOR BOTH SYSTEMS. HOLLA
May 7, 2008 5:19 PM
 

D504 said:

I have GTA IV on the PS3 and I must say I don’t have any complaints. I haven’t experienced any freezing or glitches. If you need more lighting you can always adjust it in the game just like you can change the controls from the standard setting that they start you off with to the classic mode. I don’t have a xbox and never wanted one everyone I know that has one had to send it back a time or two. I will leave you with this to think on if xbox is a better system then why did they spend a extra 50 mil just to try and give them an advantage over the PS3.
May 7, 2008 5:22 PM
 

Nex Gin said:

@JFrank2040 & @G-RootTHEJudge

Yall dudes is too funny.  For the most part you are correct though but the fractional difference is so miniscule that its not ever worth mentioning.  Every publication that has rated the 2 versions has either gave them a tie or the PS3 a 1 point lead (100-99).  I can speak on this as a former sony supporter who wouldn't touch xbox.  Now I ain't fuckin' with the PS3 unless they get a shitload of hot exclusives (MGS3 and FF won't be enough).  PS3 users have complained about freezing and shit.  Haven't experienced that yet on the 360.  Plus, the average player could give a shit less about the partical affects, etc.  You'd have to be super geek to notice or even give a damn.
IMO if I had to choose a system to buy and get this game, it would be 360.  The overall benefits of the 360 clearly beat out ps3 when you include that fact that most games nowadays are coming out on both systems, xbox is cheaper and has better online.  All Sony has going for it is Blu-Ray (which Microsoft will surely include in newer models) and slightly better graphics/performance.

If you wanna get busted on COD4 holla at gamer tag AcP 333.
May 7, 2008 5:24 PM
 

Just_In said:

@brooklynbanger
Do u fuck wit COD4 on the 3? If so hit me up, PSN-Just_In
May 7, 2008 5:32 PM
 

big4mat said:

I DON'T HAVE IT FOR PS3 BANGER BUT I WILL GO COP IT FOR 3 IN A WEEK OR SO, I PLAYED IT ONLINE FOR THE 360 IT WAS HOT, I WANNA TRY IT FOR PS3.
May 7, 2008 6:33 PM
 

big4mat said:

i got to comment on the difference between both PS3 AND 360...REALLY i DON'T GIVE A FU-- REASON SAYING, WHEN i AM PLAYING, i LOVE MY ACTION FAT, DON'T MATTER WHO HAS THE SMOOTHER GRAPHICS OR WHATEVER, BUT i WILL SAY THIS THOUGH, MY GFIRST 360 BLEW UP WITH RED RING ISH, mICROSOFT SENT ME ANOTHER ONE..IT WAS NOT NEW, IS A  RFURB i THINK, AND ITS LOUD LIKE A DAMN JET IN THE ROOM LOL  I THINK THAT MOST PEOPLE SHOULD BUY BOTH...THERE IS ADVANTAGES TO BOTH..HOLLA
May 7, 2008 6:38 PM
 

MD-2-BX VIA I95 said:

NOTICE THE BIG PUN MURAL WHEN YOU GET TO SOUTH BOHAM AKA THE BX... GAME TOOK GRAPHIC DETAIL TO NEW HEIGHTS!
May 8, 2008 8:29 AM
 

Da Scope said:

 JFrank2040 said:
Alot of Sony Fanboys in here.........

So if Sony does'nt get the extra content how is that the better version?
Also Sony does'nt have no where near the amount of people online that Xbox Live has, so how is that the better version?

The ONLY reason PS3 loads faster is because you MUST mandatorily INSTALL the game to your hardrive like PC games which takes any where from 10-20 mins.

Also PS3 users are experencing FREEZING in the game.  
============================================

SORRY BUT I HAVE TO SOME WHAT DISAGREE......... I've had to exchange my 360 version of GTA4 twice because It kept freezing and then not even loading up at all, or teling me unreadable disc... And yes I got the 360 version because I felt the multiplayer would be better, but if you can't even load up, what's the point, so I exchanged it for the PS3 version (and yes I own both system, so no need for any fanboy responses)... Also I think the lighting on the 360 is not as good like you say.  Plus isn't the extra content for the 360 going to cost... so that means I have to pay $60 for the game, $50 for a year of Live, and then dish out more money for the extra content, NO THANK YOU... You can keep your extra content, cause by then, I probably will be done with the game and getting ready for Madden 09.... Also GTA4 just feels more natural on the PS3 and with the Sony controler, since that is what I've been playing all the other versions on....
May 8, 2008 12:32 PM
 

Just_In said:

You guys need to give up arguing which one is the best. There is no major difference except for the fact that Xbox doesnt have blu ray, both have advantages/disadvantages so it really doesnt matter which one is better, it's merely a matter of personal preference. Anyway for the PS cats who like gettin their head bust come see.
May 8, 2008 1:40 PM
 

JFrank2040 said:

http://boardsus.playstation.com/playstation/board/message?board.id=gta&thread.id=402213

GTAIV freezing on PS3. The only problem people had with the 360 is the Red Ring Of Death. With ANY new console new to the market there will be problems. Any other consoles that came out within the last year NEVER had any problems.

To top it off Microsoft extended the warranty from 90 days to 3 years, NO COMPANY HAS DONE THAT!.

So anything happens to your system within 3 years send it in and it will get fixed or replaced.

3-6 months from now Xbox users will be the ONLY ones with the option to buy additional game content for GTA IV, Sony will not.

ANYONE who plays online knows the more people the better, the better online service the better matches, friends, and experience you will have.

Also in my household there is a PS3, Wii, and 360.
Anyone who has all 3 will tell you the Xbox is the better gaming machine and the better online service.

Go read any website or review and always in multi platform games the 360 comes out on top.
Yes Ps3 loads faster ( GTAIV) but that's after you have to install the game......

I'm done
May 8, 2008 2:09 PM
 

mIkE dA cHaMp said:

the game is sick as hell.

does PS3 have mutliplayer or is it just LIVE on 360?

ima 360 advocate so idk
May 9, 2008 10:20 AM
 

Da Realeast nigga Out said:

Ps3 Is Better Flat Out!! I've Had Ever Game System Damn Near Invented So I Know Da History Behind Da Reason For Dem Creating These Shitts,They Based On Competition But They Can Only Do So Much With How Hi-Tech They Build Them for Consumer Pocket Reasons,Some Of Ya'll Old Enuff Probally 2 Know Nintendo & Sega Aint Friends/... Then Sega Cd Vs Super Nintendo Then Playstation Which Is Was Partnered With Nintendo 10 Years before Then.Da Sega DreamCast Which U See Is Out Of Here Couldn't Survive Playstion & They Caked It! Round 2 Ps2 Then Mr.Microsoft Wanna Get In Da Game Just 4 Da Sport And Ps2 Still Came Out On Top...Da Very Top Of Da Console Game Ps3 Did It As Well & They Been Winning Since Niggaz Diapers Bottom Line Is Wit Me I've Always Knew What Console To Pay 4 And People Just Want Xbox To Be Da Shit Cuz It's Da first Best "New Generation" Console Since Da Playstation & Dreamcast Days And Dats Da Truth.Yeah I Experienced Da Glitches But I Barely Cut My Shit Off,That's What All Electronics Do Niggaz Ipods Freeze, 3 grand cpu's crash,Sega & Nintendo Used To Freeze Remember Blowin In Da Cartridge,Cell Phones,Speakers Blow All That's Da Phisics Of a Circut Board If U A Person That Likes 2 Be Diffrent And Not Like Shit Just Becuz U A Most Likely Are A Xbox Fan/If You played Sega Over Super Nintendo..U Probally A Xbox Fan/If You Actually Owned All Video Consoles U's A Playstation Fan!!!How Come Xbox Fans Always Be Da First One To Talk Shit About Da Ps3?Can't Say Nothing Nice About It Just Fuck Ps3.As Far As I'm Concerned Xbox Loverz R Hataz/On da Behalf Of Da Ps3 Community We Don't Give A Fuck What ya'll think Cuz We Already Know Da Dealeo Nawmeen!..And I'm A Beast On Da Cod 4 Ps3 Straight Killa I'll Probally Be On It Thursday "Reese5662" Xbox Killa Just 4 Da Fuck Of It!
May 11, 2008 12:31 AM
 

skitzofraen said:

JFrank2040 said

"The graphics are equal, as PS3 has better explosions and AA, but the Xbox has better Lighting and sharpness."

The xbox 360 have 2x AA... the PS3 doesn't have AA at all (look it up if you don't want to take my word for it)

The explosions are exactly the same... The PS3 loads faster (like 5-10 seconds)... the 360 runs at 720p while the PS3 runs at 640p (the ps3 version isn't even HD, its an SD signal upscaled to hd)

The 360 version runs at a better framerate (like 5-8 frames more per second)

Other than that there's no difference between the versions...



May 13, 2008 1:04 PM
Anonymous comments are disabled. Sign up or Login
Lifestyle Archives
 >