Did Cliven Bundy Inherit His Land Because of a Government Handout?

In the circus that has become American politics, a recurring ploy by the conservative right wing has become evident. Repeatedly, reactionary conservatives latch on to some random citizen, often a White male, as the embodiment of all the virtue of their self proclaimed noble struggle against the abuses of government. During the 2008 election it was the rather vapid figure Joe “The Plumber” who filled that role, and today that character is the gun slinging cattle rancher Cliven Bundy.

Bundy’s dispute stems from the fact that his cows have been grazing on federal land in the state of Nevada for over 20 years without paying the required grazing fees. Bundy accumulated over $1 million dollars in fees and went through several court actions claiming “States Rights,” arguing the land belonged to Nevada and not the Federal Government.

Therefore, Bundy claimed his rights as a citizen of Nevada were being encroached upon. Bundy lost all those court battles. When federal authorities began to seize Bundy’s illegally grazing cattle he alerted his fellow local ranchers for support and staged an “O.K. Corral” type of stand off likened to a scene from the classic TV Western Bonanza. Right wing media, always seeking to score points in the Obama age, caught on to the story and caused a Republican circling of the wagons around Clive Bundy’s cause. Of course Republicans have no problem with the government using tax payer dollars to fund spurious military exploits and savagely brutal drone campaigns, but when a clearly wrongheaded cattle herder who fits their ideological profile offers the ability to make great talking points, why not join the party.

From this link: 

“His cause has won support from Senator Rand Paul, the libertarian
Republican from Kentucky who is likely to run for president. Senator
Dean Heller, a Nevada Republican, referred to Mr. Bundy’s supporters as
“patriots.” Senator Harry Reid, the Nevada Democrat who is the Senate
majority leader and has a long history of pushing for protection of
public lands, denounced the rancher’s supporters as “domestic

One of the greatest ironies about all this claptrap by Republicans about the Federal Government “abusing its authority” in what they are billing as over-reach is that little attention has been payed to the likely way Bundy acquired his “family land” in the first place.  According to reports, Bundy inherited his land from his ancestors who “settled” there in the 1880s. In the wake of racially charged statements Bundy spewed asserting that Blacks would have been better off if still slaves as opposed to doing nothing as he perceives them to be, it’s interesting to note that maybe if those supposed Blacks got hundreds of acres of land in a free government handout like Bundy’s ancestors probably did, he’d think twice about making such ridiculous comments. Between 1862 and 1976 the United States government gave hundreds of thousands of acres of land to the White poor to graze and populate the great western expanse often for FREE. The program was called the Homestead Act.

Over ten percent of all the land in the United States was given to poor whites to economically empower themselves starting under Abraham Lincoln while at the same time Black people were being denied 40 Acres and a mule. For Clive Bundy, a likely beneficiary of this program, to have the nerve to even prattle on about government abuse, and even better, yammer on about lack of Black initiative, in the face of the Federal Government probably bankrolling his whole family’s estate over a century ago is beyond comical, it’s offensive. The United States government has NEVER made a bona fide effort to repair the economic gulf caused by both slavery and Jim Crow–which lasted well into the 60’s in comparison to what was done to lift the White poor into the middle and upper middle class. This includes not only the Homestead act, but also the New Deal which lifted the white poor well into the middle and upper middle class into the 20th Century. Ira Katznelson, in his treatise, “When Affirmative Action was White,” does an excellent job of listing the ways Southern Segregationist Senators denied benefits from the Social Security Act to the GI Bill to the super majority of Blacks who lived in the South in order to maintain the economic exploitation of Black labor under Jim Crow.  So next time you hear Jonathan Chait, Paul Ryan, or even Barack Obama prattle on about some “cultural defect” in the Black poor remind them that the only defect is that poor Blacks didn’t get the economic gravy train that has been given to poor Whites since the 1860s.

Though this is a digression, this all plays well into the fallacy of how the Supreme Court, or anyone else, can argue that enough has been done to level the playing field for Blacks, and affirmative action is no longer needed. There is not enough policy on the planet that could properly adjust Black people in America for the economic loss and damage caused to them because of White Supremacy. The fact that Affirmative Action for whites  – which is partially listed in this link – has been going on unbounded well into the 20th century should alert anyone to how much the chips have been stacked in one groups favor to the detriment of another group.

Here is an excellent video of Dr. Martin Luther King discussing how ridiculous it is for people to expect Blacks to “lift themselves up by their bootstraps” when compared to the bailout the white poor and working class have been getting for over a century: MLK on Economic Justice

  • Pingback: Did Cliven Bundy Inherit His Land Because of a Government Handout? - Bmore Gossip()

  • Andy

    Good article, the stupidity of some old, far right wing Americans never ceases to amaze me.

  • This is some high power stuff!

  • Pingback: Did Cliven Bundy Inherit His Land Because of a Government Handout? | HIP HOP WORLDWIDE()

  • Pingback: Did Cliven Bundy Inherit His Land Because of a Government Handout? - Pro City Vault()

  • wickedjones

    Excellent article. Notice there’s not too many comments on this story. I guess you need to put more weave pulling, and weed smoking in the story.


      This is just the beginning. He’s not the only one that think like this. This the Sh*t people should be outspoken about. They scared. know their time is running out. Another ten years and the right wing will be a thing of the past. It will be a few left. Not enough to do any damage.

    • AlbertoRipRon

      Yea you right. This isn’t about Housewives of some city featuring fouled mouth hoes and niggas who pass them around like a white owl, so blacks don’t even care. It’s absolutely frustrating.

  • Pingback: Example Of White Welfare: The Bundy Ranch - 4UMF : 4UMF()


    Good read……stormcloudsgathering on utube has a good piece on this as well as many other issues…..thank me later

  • whatupdoe

    Crazy part is how many people of all races will agree with his bullshit and say he has a point without thinking.

    • InTheNightKitchen

      Who are you referring to? Who’s bullshit?

      • Troll_E_G

        Its a ploy for diversion. Whites do this all the time

      • InTheNightKitchen

        Ahh ok, I gotchu X2

  • InTheNightKitchen

    Thank you for this informative piece of info. Links, video, and all.

  • Its funny the difference a day makes; most of his support is gone after asking if “the nigra” was better off during slavery. Of course some of these people probably agree but have to publically have to distance themselves. I think a vast amount of white Americans feel the same way. Its just the hight of irony that he’s mooching off the government.

  • AlbertoRipRon

    Of course. But when blacks will realize this and stop all their foolishness? Sadly, never. Too worried about looking fly. So while this is informative and good to know, it really does nothing for blacks. They continually ignore the issues that matter just so that they can continue looking rich but not wealthy. If blacks don’t come together and go head on against this, they won’t ever succeed. And they will never. The monkey theory says so. Black people are too indoctrinated into the system, whether they acknowledge or not.

    • Mark Olford

      Problem is Alberto the machine doesn’t want you to see the blacks that are doing it out of the system. Not all of us are how we are portrayed on this website and BET bud….the machine, or system wants people to continue to believe the stereotype…look at the Clippers owner comments….anyways, I think you get my point..

      • AlbertoRipRon

        But it doesn’t need to be mentioned though. It’s simple math bruh. We all know that there are 90 percent of people in the world who aren’t worth shit while the small 10 percent is barely visible.

        Yet and still at the end of the spectrum, if the “good” ones were highly productive, then how come black people in society don’t have no place? Which leads back to black folks not working together to have monopolies and business assets that aid their people. White folks have that. Asians have that. Indians have that. Each one of those racial groups don’t have any clear distinct separation within their race. They are more united and driven to honor not only their families but their ethnicity as a whole. Black people don’t have that. Black people have no power, except just voting power.

        I know about the machine. I’ve seen it work. I’m not oblivious to it. But I’m also not going to pull punches with blacks either. Blacks are highly disorganized and unmotivated. Even “good” blacks or the ones not portrayed in BET and websites, don’t even mess with their own people.

        This is just the truth bruh. Like you did, black folks just point fingers instead of just saying “hey, we fucked up. Now how can we unite to bring us to higher plateau instead of wallowing in shit and have no respect for ourselves”

        And about the Clippers guy, how the NAACP giving him a lifetime achievement award? Maybe its news for the masses just now, but dude ALWAYS been on some racist shit. How does the NAACP not know that? This is what I mean, black folks gotta stop snoozing out here and being stupid. Getting stepped on and don’t care.

        Black folks have no power or respect from ANY racial class. How is that even possible bruh?

      • Tommyzax

        Unfortunately, not only possible but probable. I like your stance. Keep asking questions, and eventually the truth must come to the surface. All these people are messed up because they don’t believe in God’s Law. Peace.

      • AlbertoRipRon

        Peace unto you.

      • SBRon

        Care to elaborate on “God’s Law”…?

  • Tommyzax

    Southern DEMOCRAT segregationists.

  • Isaac Hayes

    Good article I will most definitely read up on the points you made here.

  • NYRss1001

    The author assumes Bundy “likely” benefited… Just as Bundy assumed blacks are doing nothing…

    I assume that Bundny is the owner of the land and blacks are working very hard.

  • Chris Brooks

    We supply the following chemical products:
    UR-144, 5FUR-144
    Mephedrone (4-MMC)
    Methylone (bk-MDMA)
    Bulytone (bk-MBDB),
    JWH-018 / JWH-250,,
    Bromo DragonFly
    Fast Delivery. -Discreet Packaging.
    Express Delivery
    text(832) 447-2634 or