Consequence Flies Kyte To Stay Hot
10-10-2008, 3:37 PM | 8







Madonna: Hard Candy Album Review 
Published Friday, April 25, 2008 2:00 PM
Facebook ADD TO DEL.ICIO.US ADD TO DIGG ADD TO GOOGLE ADD TO TECHNORATI FAVORITES
By Alex Thornton

The image “http://209.18.98.116/promo/images/star3.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.


Madonna has released a Dance-pop album called Hard Candy produced by Timbaland, Justin Timberlake and Pharrell; no further description is necessary. Even with the not-as-good-as-you’d-hope lead single “4 Minutes,” it’s hard not to have dangerously high expectations for this album.

Every female Pop star of the last 25 years has at least partially modeled herself after Madonna, and the artists that make up the production team have been responsible for some of the finest Pop and R&B of the last ten.

Expectation is art’s worst enemy, but with this much talent gathered together, could anything possibly go wrong?

Apparently not. While Hard Candy does have some academic problems to be found if you’re looking for them, every track is above average and the album stays enjoyable throughout. In the best moments.

Her Madgesty is closer to the Madonna we met in the ‘80s than she has been in years, because Hard Candy drops the art-house intentions of her recent work and gets her back to the roots.

Pharrell in particular seems to understand her intimately, and it’s on his tracks that Madonna really feels like The Material Girl again.

The (relatively) mid-tempo “Heartbeat” and “She’s Not Me” accentuate Madonna’s strengths without overextending her range or smothering her with pretentious tracks that steal the show from her vocals.

Despite clocking in at over six minutes, “Incredible” manages to stay interesting by switching tones and remaining fluid, and though “Spanish Lesson” leans more towards Pharrell than Madonna, the core of the song still properly retains her attitude.

Surprising as it may sound, Tim and Justin hold up their end of the bargain in a general sense but… something is missing. Timberlake is undeniably gifted but still seems unable to write a song for another artist that doesn’t sound like he originally wrote it for himself.

While this may be good enough for a Rihanna, “Devil Wouldn’t Recognize You” loses the Madonna element and therefore seems a little less special than it should. “4 Minutes” has a similar problem.

Timbaland doesn’t stretch far enough beyond his usual tactics, making it feel less like a real collaboration and more like some song that Tim and Justin brought to the studio and told her to sing.

A decent Timbaland track is always likeable and there’s really nothing wrong with anything he’s done, but it’s a tad disappointing that he neither innovates a new sound for Madonna nor reinterprets any of her old ones; he merely wanders around the middle instead.

As a well-known expert at reinvention, most of Madonna’s various albums aren’t truly comparable so attempting to rank Hard Candy against her 25 years of releases is pointless if not impossible.

It can be said, however, that it’s one of her best overall works (especially of the last decade or so) and for a woman with a career older than a lot of her fans, that’s a high compliment. Simply put, Madonna has done it again; what did you expect?


Comments

 

doobie ashtray said:

INTERESTING... BUT NOT REALLY A MADONNA FAN.... DIRTY HARRY DID A NICE BLEND WITH ONE OF HER TRACKS OVER THE MOBB DEEP TWISTED BEAT THATS PROB THE ONLY MADONNA JOINT YOULL CATCH ME BUMPIN
April 25, 2008 2:07 PM
 

jthagreat said:

last
April 25, 2008 2:09 PM
 

gaboi_706 said:

I will download this BUT if I like i will go and buy it shii with Danja (not Timbaland) and Pharrell producin it......I know the beats are going to be crazy
April 25, 2008 2:10 PM
 

kayfizzle said:

Madonna is such the pioneer of a white woman crossing over black,but I'm still shocked Allhiphop.com did a review..I've been a fan of Madge since I was a kid..."Borderline" was the song that made me a huge fan..be4 Eminem and Britney..she was played on black radio!..I'm glad to see her get good reviews on a hip hop site..seeing that she is The Queen Of Pop!...I cannot wait to get this album..sounds like her best work since "Ray Of Light!".......
April 25, 2008 2:31 PM
 

Swytch said:

April 25, 2008 2:52 PM
 

Que4Real said:

Im Sayin Madonna............ AHH Yall fallin off 4 this one!!!!

http://www.gothaze.com/
http://www.gothaze.com/

April 25, 2008 3:05 PM
 

Theyztenz said:

Madonna could teach Hip Hop a lesson...25 years in the game and still killin' it.  Take notes ya'll...
April 25, 2008 4:02 PM
 

Pilly Da Kid said:

Fuck that duck, quack, zoo, foot, elephant toe slimed-filled bucket of vagina ass Madonna. THIS IS HIP-HOP NIGGA.
April 25, 2008 4:22 PM
 

Cholo1510 said:

She's richer than any rapper in the game..THe only girl really fucking with her is Mariah and Janet...Thats cool i like that the site is open-minded...If you like techno that last album of hers is fierce
April 25, 2008 4:34 PM
 

Tommy K. said:

Dang she came hard like that? That's a high rating. I will check it out.
April 25, 2008 5:12 PM
 

Que4Real said:

They gave this youngin a review off the strength of her having hip hop producers on the album!!!!! She has money so thats not hard to do!! She's like 78 years old right?????

http://www.gothaze.com/
http://www.gothaze.com/
April 25, 2008 5:20 PM
 

MACCAPONE said:

WACC
April 25, 2008 7:08 PM
 

bosshogg83 said:

gaboi_706 actually it was a team effort with Tim/Danja Jt or Tim/Hannon/Jt do your research and the album is good my favorite is Miles Away the Neptunes are coming back.
April 25, 2008 7:38 PM
 

rapindaclub said:

album will have overall hiphop/rnb feel! shes always good!!!
April 25, 2008 8:21 PM
 

slimturk said:

@ Pilly Da Kid,

And she is now half HipHop.....sop hate all you want....She got more bread then any hip hop artist in the game....

***********************************

This is amazing that Madonna has been able to still be successful after so many damn years in the music industry....How many albums has she released up to this date......Damn this girl is damn lucky to survive this long...
April 25, 2008 9:05 PM
 

gargameljermel said:

Madonna always like to flirt with R&B and hip hop shit since the 90's (Take a Bow written and produced by Babyface for example) so she alright by me. Shit that 4 minutes joint is at least more decent than some of the bull shit r&b they got coming out today.
April 25, 2008 11:26 PM
 

Cresent City Connektor said:

The Material Girl has always been in my good graces!!!! Do ya thing Madonna!!! I will peep this as well!
April 26, 2008 10:21 AM
 

mc2da said:

yo she can't even sing she's made her whole career off controversy, you ever hear her live its terrible she's on the same level singing wise as britney but she's pimped the game so good for her but she won't get my dime  and how the hell is justin timberlake a producer  now you got brothers out there been producing for year and can't catch a break and now this dude is a producer its a joke, i guess its its who you know and britney more money than nas common talib kweli, the game, and a bunch of others rappers so what does loot gotto wit it, it don't make you talented ask brass knuckles she's not even american anymore
April 26, 2008 11:18 AM
 

Dove said:


Madonna has always known how to follow the right producers to get a sound that will be ahead of the curve. From her first album working with Jellybean Benitez, she knew how to get people's attention. Look at what she did with Ray Of Light - that was some completely off the wall stuff IMO. She never does what we expect. Now if only some of these up and coming artists would take note. Don't do what's hot NOW, do what's going to be hot tomorrow and for the long run.
April 26, 2008 1:00 PM
 

illseed said:

madonna is ill. i aint even mad at this CD. she's an incredible performer and morphs at will. who's really messing with that?
 
mc2da - this has almost nothing to do with timberlake and race and "brothers"...both pharrell and timbaland are all over this album. madonna gets the overall thumbs up and its got absol-damn-nothing to do with no damn nas, common, talib kweli, the game or any other rapper....whats wrong with people? got buy to janet albums if you tht angry.
April 27, 2008 11:59 AM
 

Hard Candy Allhiphop Review / The Neptunes #1 fan site said:

April 27, 2008 9:03 PM
 

Shifty_UK said:

incredible sounding album. people need to open thier minds a little. also learn some respect.

shes not the highest selling female artist for no reason. theres never smoke without fire she a musical pioneer and knows how to work the industry like a pimp works a hoe.
April 28, 2008 11:02 AM
 

Dharma1 said:

Madonna's Hip Hop She was Fucking 2Pac, and Big Daddy Kane and Gransmaster D from Whodini etc....
May 2, 2008 5:27 PM
Anonymous comments are disabled. Sign up or Login
Alternatives Archives
 >